Policy-as-Code with Tests; Deny by Default By CyberDudeBivash — Ruthless, Engineering-Grade Threat Intel for 2025

August 15, 2025

Policy-as-Code with Tests; Deny by Default By CyberDudeBivash — Ruthless, Engineering-Grade Threat Intel for 2025

Author: CyberDudeBivash • Powered by: CyberDudeBivash
Links: cyberdudebivash.com | cyberbivash.blogspot.com
Hashtag: #cyberdudebivash

Executive Summary

In modern cloud-native and API-driven environments, security policies can’t live in PDFs or tribal knowledge—they must live in code. Policy-as-Code (PaC) operationalizes this idea: encode access rules, security guardrails, and compliance checks as machine-readable logic that integrates directly with CI/CD pipelines, service meshes, and infrastructure.

But code without discipline is chaos. That’s why PaC must be tested like application code—with unit, integration, and regression tests that prove policies work as intended. And to contain blast radius, “deny by default” must be the starting state: everything blocked unless explicitly allowed.

This article explores how enterprises can implement Policy-as-Code with a test-driven, deny-first mindset—ensuring that trust is earned, not assumed.

Why Policy-as-Code?

Speed vs Security
- DevOps pushes features daily, but compliance and security approvals can’t lag weeks behind.
- PaC allows automated enforcement at commit and runtime, eliminating bottlenecks.
Consistency
- One policy language (OPA/Rego, Sentinel, Kyverno, etc.) ensures that Kubernetes, cloud IAM, APIs, and services enforce the same rules.
Auditability
- Every policy change is tracked in Git, versioned, peer-reviewed, and tested.
- Regulators get provable evidence instead of tribal “we think it’s secure.”
Shift-left Security
- Catch violations early in CI/CD, not at runtime.
- Example: deny Terraform plan if it tries to create a public S3 bucket or wide-open security group.

The Core Principle: Deny by Default

“Deny by default” means no implicit trust. The burden is on developers/ops to prove why a request should be allowed.

Access Control: Default is no access. Add explicit allow rules for users, services, and APIs.
Network Security: Default deny egress/ingress, then open only approved destinations/ports.
Cloud Resources: No public IPs, no wildcard principals (*), no unencrypted storage—unless explicitly justified.
APIs: All routes require auth; unknown fields rejected; schema drift denied.

This model not only reduces attack surface but also forces clarity: if you can’t justify why it should be allowed, it shouldn’t be allowed.

Policy-as-Code + Tests = Real Security

Why testing policies matters:

Prevent policy drift (rules written but never enforced).
Catch logic bugs (e.g., a “read-only” policy that accidentally allows DELETE).
Ensure regressions don’t reappear when policies evolve.

Testing Approaches:

Unit Tests
- Validate policy logic in isolation.
- Example: Test that “only users in admin role can access /v1/admin/*.”
Integration Tests
- Simulate real requests through API gateways or Kubernetes admission controllers.
- Ensure enforcement works end-to-end.
Regression Tests
- Re-test every past policy bug to ensure it never returns.
Negative Testing
- Prove that invalid, risky, or malicious requests are denied.
- Example: Verify that an S3 bucket creation with public-read ACL is rejected.

Practical Implementation Blueprint

Step 1: Choose a Policy Engine

OPA/Rego (Open Policy Agent): Cloud-native, works with Kubernetes, APIs, microservices.
HashiCorp Sentinel: Terraform, Vault, Consul native.
Kyverno: Kubernetes-native, YAML-based policies.

Step 2: Define Policy Categories

Identity & Access: RBAC/ABAC for APIs and services.
Infrastructure Guardrails: Cloud config (S3 private, IAM least privilege).
Network: Egress restrictions, segmentation, TLS enforcement.
Data Security: Encryption in transit/at rest, data classification.

Step 3: Enforce Deny-by-Default

Start with zero permissions, zero network flows, zero resource exposure.
Build allow rules only after business justification.

Step 4: Build a Test Suite

Store tests alongside policies in Git.
Run tests in CI/CD before merging.
Block merges on failed policy tests.

Step 5: Deploy Incrementally

Shadow mode first (log denies).
Tighten gradually.
Monitor impacts via observability and logs.

Code Examples

OPA/Rego Example: Deny by Default


package httpapi.authz

default allow = false

# Allow only GET requests to /profile for users with "user" role
allow {
  input.method == "GET"
  input.path == ["v1", "profile"]
  input.user.role == "user"
}

Unit Test for Rego Policy


test_get_profile_user {
  allow with input as {"method": "GET", "path": ["v1", "profile"], "user": {"role": "user"}}
}

test_delete_profile_denied {
  not allow with input as {"method": "DELETE", "path": ["v1", "profile"], "user": {"role": "user"}}
}

Terraform + Sentinel Example


# Deny creation of public S3 buckets
import "tfplan/v2" as tfplan

main = rule {
  all tfplan.resources.aws_s3_bucket as _, bucket {
    bucket.applied.acl != "public-read"
    bucket.applied.acl != "public-read-write"
  }
}

Operational Guardrails

All policies versioned in Git.
Policies peer-reviewed like app code.
CI/CD runs policy tests before merge.
Deny by default enforced at gateways and admission controllers.
All policy changes generate audit logs.
Break-glass exceptions logged, time-boxed, and reviewed.

KPIs for Policy-as-Code Programs

Policy Coverage: % of APIs, infra, and services with policies in place.
Test Coverage: % of policies with automated tests.
Block Rate: How many risky changes blocked in CI/CD vs runtime.
Mean Time to Deny (MTTD): Speed at which violations are denied.
Auditability: % of policies with logs + version history.

Final Word

Policy-as-Code with tests and deny-by-default isn’t a technical choice—it’s a survival strategy in the face of cloud sprawl, API-first architectures, and AI-driven automation.

If your policies live only in wiki pages, attackers already won. If your policies don’t default to deny, you’re trusting ghosts. And if your policies aren’t tested, you’re gambling on security.

Code it, test it, deny first. That’s the CyberDudeBivash way.

#PolicyAsCode #ZeroTrust #CyberDudeBivash #OPA #Rego #Kyverno #Sentinel #DevSecOps #CloudSecurity #APISecurity #CI/CD

Search This Blog

Cyberdudebivash